Theme: The Tony Awards (Part 3)
Notes: This third part of our annual Tony Awards review covered all the award ceremonies from the 1990's and 2000's (1990-2005) and completed our review for 2005.
| Song | Show | Source |
| Overture | The Light in the Piazza | 2005 Original New York Cast |
| I'm Nothing Without You | City of Angels | 1990 Original New York Cast |
| Give a Man Enough Rope | Will Rogers Follies | 1991 Original New York Cast |
| Stiff Upper Lip | Crazy for You | 1992 Original New York Cast |
| I Do Miracles | Kiss of the Spider Woman | 1993 Original New York Cast |
| I Wish I Could Forget You | Passion | 1994 Original New York Cast |
| With One Look | Sunset Boulevard | 1995 Original New York Cast |
| Rent | Rent | 1996 Original New York Cast |
| In Every Age (Finale) | Titanic | 1997 Original New York Cast |
| The Morning Report | The Lion King | 1998 Original New York Cast |
| I Gotcha | Fosse | 1999 Original New York Cast |
| You're Nobody Till Somebody Loves You | Contact | 2000 Original New York Cast |
| We Can Do It | The Producers | 2001 Original New York Cast |
| Not for the Life of Me / Thoroughly Modern Millie | Thoroughly Modern Millie | 2002 Original New York Cast |
| You're Timeless to Me | Hairspray | 2003 Original New York Cast |
| There is Life Outside Your Apartment | Avenue Q | 2004 Original New York Cast |
| Run Away! | Spamalot | 2005 Original New York Cast |